Tuesday , November 17 2026

Are the rules different for whites? ICC report on Perth Test created uproar:

[ad_1]

Posts

News India Live, Digital Desk: Cricket fans, today we have to talk about a very serious issue which will force you to think. Are the rules of cricket the same for everyone, or are decisions changed depending on ‘home’?

The latest case is from Perth. The first test match of the Ashes series being played between Australia and England. It was expected that there would be a tough fight over five days, but what happened? The match is just for two days, yes, just two days I am over! For the batsmen, staying at the crease was like fighting a war. 19 wickets fell on the very first day. But the surprising thing is not the result of the match, but the decision of ICC after the match.

Told the 2 day match as ‘Very Good’
Everyone thought that just like in India, if a match ends in 3 days, the ICC gives a ‘Poor’ or ‘Average’ rating, something similar would happen here too. But no, you will be surprised to know that ICC has banned that Perth pitch. “Very Good” Rated!

Strange logic of match referee
Match referee Ranjan Madugalle said in his report that there was a “good balance between ball and bat” on the Perth pitch. He argued that the initial seam movement and bounce on the pitch was perfect. According to him, even though the match ended early, it was not the fault of the pitch, rather it was a brilliant performance by the bowlers.

Now the question arises that when the same thing happens in India, why does the perspective change?

The ‘duplicity’ between spin and pace
Just look back. When the magic of spinners works in India and the match ends within 3 days (like it happened in Indore or Ahmedabad), then the legends from all over the world and the ICC itself call it ‘Average’ or ‘Poor’. It is said that the pitch was not fit for batting.

So is the dominance of pace bowlers the “class of cricket” and the dominance of spin bowlers “the fault of the pitch”?

Indian fans are asking this same question on social media. This was the shortest match (in terms of balls) in Ashes history since 1888 in Perth. The game ended in just 847 balls. Nevertheless it was given the label of “sporting wicket”.

Is this a lesson for Indian cricket?
This incident has once again sparked debate. Is ICC’s criteria for judging Asian pitches different from Western countries? There is chaos when dust flies in our house, but when the ball bounces like a marble in Perth or Gabba, it is called ‘real Test cricket’.

It has stuck in the minds of the fans that perhaps the rules are the same, but the spectacles are different. However, what is your opinion on this ‘Very Good’ rating of Perth? Do you also think that ICC needs to improve its standards?

Cricket is a game of uncertainties, but if the decisions are certain and fair, then only then is the real fun of the game.

[ad_2]